top of page
Search

The NIL Truth: Emily Staker on the Portal, Path to the Pros, and Keeping the Main Thing the Main Thing

  • tbdomann
  • Jul 1
  • 8 min read


From Pro Mindset® Podcast with Host Craig Domann, featuring Emily Staker, sports attorney, NFLPA-certified agent, and one of the leading NIL agents in college football. 


There has never been more money in college athletics. There has also never been more confusion, more bad advice, and more families making life-altering decisions without fully understanding the rules of the game they're signing on to play.


Emily Staker is one of the few people in this space who can tell you exactly what's going wrong — and why. A barred attorney, NFLPA-certified agent, and one of the leading NIL representatives in college football, Emily didn't arrive at this level by accident. She learned the business from the ground up, including under the mentorship of Pro Mindset® host Craig Domann himself. At the end of the conversation, she said it plainly: "I had a great teacher in all of this. Thank you for teaching me everything you know, because that was a huge part of who I am today."


That foundation shows in everything she does. Emily joined Domann for a conversation that cut through the noise and got straight to what athletes and their families actually need to know.


The message she kept coming back to was simple, even if the landscape around it is anything but: keep the main thing the main thing.


Before NIL, agents weren't reaching out to players until their sophomore or junior year of college. Today, Emily is having conversations with families when their sons are sophomores in high school — sometimes before a star rating has even been assigned. The entire timeline of recruiting, representation, and compensation has compressed dramatically, and most families are navigating it without a map.


"A lot of families don't even really understand that schools are able to compensate players directly now," Emily told Craig. "So a lot of it has become much more distilled into building that basic sense of trust."


For Emily, the first priority when working with minors is minimizing direct contact and getting in front of mom and dad. As an attorney, she understands the ethical weight of those early conversations. But beyond legal compliance, her emphasis is on education — helping families understand what NIL actually is, how the compensation structures work, and most critically, what the right questions are when a school comes calling with a big number.


Because the big number is where most families go wrong.


The most common error Emily sees families make is treating the highest NIL offer as the default best option. It sounds logical on the surface. But in practice, chasing the biggest check without considering the full picture is one of the fastest ways to derail a young athlete's path to the NFL.


"This school might be offering the most," she explained, "but he'd be the fifth tight end on the roster. He might not ever see the field."


And if he doesn't see the field, NFL scouts can't see him. It's that straightforward. The combine is already getting harder every year because players are transferring repeatedly or landing at programs where they never play. Scouts can't evaluate what they can't watch.


Emily's framework for every college decision starts with non-monetary factors: Is the culture a good fit? Will he actually get on the field? Does he trust the coaching staff? Is the program stable, or is the head coach likely to leave by January? Can the family realistically afford to travel for every game? Only after those questions are answered — and answered well — does the money conversation begin.


"If you're making fifty thousand more and it stops your ability to go to the league," Craig put it plainly, "that fifty thousand was not worth it."


Emily's response was equally plain: not at all.


One of the most practically important parts of the conversation was Emily's breakdown of the NILGO platform — the approval system that now governs all Division I NIL deals as a result of the House settlement.


Run by Deloitte and powered heavily by AI, NILGO reviews every submitted deal to determine whether it reflects fair market value for the work involved. If it doesn't pass the review, the deal gets kicked back for revision. The challenge is that the review process isn't fully transparent, the timing can be unpredictable, and the consequences of getting it wrong are serious.


Emily's rule for every client is non-negotiable: don't sign anything until NILGO approves it.

"The last thing you want from a contract law perspective is to sign the deal and then have it rejected through the portal," she said. "NILGO's rejection doesn't nullify the contract by law under contract law yet. So you either need to negotiate in the contract that it's subject to NILGO approval, or wait and only sign it after it's approved."


For families going through this process without experienced representation, that kind of nuance is invisible — until it becomes a very expensive problem. State laws add another layer. Colorado, for example, has its own specific laws governing how high school athletes can be paid and how those deals can be structured. An agent who hasn't done that homework before sitting down with a family isn't just unhelpful. They're potentially dangerous.


The transfer portal has become one of the most debated topics in college sports, and Emily's take is more nuanced than most. She doesn't see it as inherently good or bad. She sees it as a tool — one that works brilliantly in the right hands and causes serious damage in the wrong ones.


Used correctly, the portal is for the underdog. The player who came out of high school with two or three offers, made the most of a smaller stage, and now deserves a shot at higher competition. If a player can genuinely move up in conference level, step into a starting role, or develop behind a future NFL player at a program with real NFL pipeline, a portal move can accelerate everything.


"If it's a true jump," Emily said, "you're going to the SEC, you're gonna be a starter — that can absolutely be worth it."


But if the motivation is a lateral move for more money, she pushes back hard. More money at a program where a player has no relationship with the quarterback, no chemistry with the coaching staff, and no realistic path to playing time is not a step forward. It's a distraction dressed up as an opportunity.


NFL evaluators are watching all of this. What they want to see is performance against future NFL players — on the field, consistently, over time. A player who has bounced between three programs in four years raises questions about resilience, coachability, and whether he can stick it out when things get hard. Those questions don't have easy answers on a scouting report.


"Is that not the experience of every college player going to the NFL?" Emily asked. "Knowing that it's going to be difficult, knowing that you may not be the biggest or the fastest, and doing it anyway and succeeding — that proves a lot of legitimacy for NFL evaluators."


One of the most sobering parts of the conversation was Emily's account of a player who arrived on campus in January only to watch his entire coaching staff walk out two weeks later.


The new staff came in and told him directly: we don't have a spot for you.

This is not a hypothetical situation. It is happening with increasing frequency as the coaching carousel spins faster and faster in the post-NIL era. And with transfer portal windows now locked to specific periods of the year, a player in that situation can find himself without a roster spot and without the ability to enter the portal — a limbo that can cost him an entire season of eligibility.


Emily's response in those situations is to pursue legislative relief waivers through the NCAA, arguing that the player was blindsided and deserves the right to enter the portal outside the standard window. Some succeed. Others don't.


Her broader point was a call to action for policymakers: the current system doesn't adequately protect student athletes who are cut or displaced after the portal closes. With the new age-based eligibility model limiting players to five years total — no medical hardship extensions, no exceptions — the stakes of losing even one season have never been higher.


The solution, in her view, is having student athlete voices represented in the decision-making process. Not a nameless subcommittee rendering judgment on a young person's future in a single sentence with no explanation. A human process that actually looks the athlete in the eye.


Perhaps the most urgent warning Emily sounded in the entire conversation was about the NIL representation space itself — and who is operating in it.


There is currently no certification requirement, no oversight body, and no meaningful barrier to entry for anyone who wants to call themselves an NIL agent. Emily is a licensed attorney who passed the bar, earned her NFLPA certification, and holds herself to the ethical standards required by both. The person who adds "NIL agent" to their Instagram bio tomorrow faces zero of those requirements.


"There are people who have literally committed financial crimes who are out here representing college athletes," she said, "and there is zero recourse available to those athletes if they are misrepresented."


Some schools have taken matters into their own hands by maintaining internal lists of agents they will not work with — and in some cases, refusing to recruit players who sign with certain representatives. That's a start, Emily said. But it's not enough. A formal certification process or agent registry is needed, and it's needed now.


Her advice to every family in the meantime is to treat agent selection like any other high-stakes hire: research credentials, verify experience, check references, and ask hard questions. The person you trust with your son's NIL deals will also be the person you call when he gets a career-threatening injury and needs a second opinion from an NFL-connected physician. The difference between the right agent and the wrong one is not theoretical.


When Craig gave Emily sixty seconds to make her pitch to a hypothetical parent on the phone, she didn't lead with her credentials or her track record. She led with a question, “Are our values aligned?”


"I want that relationship for life," she said. "My expectation is that we're going from high school to college to pro and all of the years after. I am not going to make that decision lightly."


She wants to understand what motivates the player. Whether faith plays a role in how the family makes decisions. Whether his dream of playing professionally is truly his dream — not just what everyone around him has been telling him to want.


In a space that has become increasingly transactional, that perspective is worth pausing on. The best agent isn't the one who gets the biggest initial deal. It's the one who is still in the room ten years later, helping a former player figure out what comes next.


Keep the main thing the main thing. Get on the field. Develop your game. Build relationships you won't regret burning. And make sure the person guiding you through all of it has the credentials, the integrity, and the values to earn that trust.



Listen to the full conversation with Emily Staker  here or here. Connect with Craig for coaching opportunities at Craig.ProMindset@gmail.com. Find Emily at https://the.team/sports-talent/nfl-american-football and follow along for resources built for athletes, coaches, and the parents who support them.



Follow Us On:

For more information about Craig and his keynote speaking, coaching, or athlete representation, go to www.CraigDomann.com or contact him at Craig.ProMindset@gmail.com.


 
 
 

Comments

© 2023 Pro Mindset

bottom of page