Master Your Inner Levers with Leadership Coach Randy Lyman

From Pro Mindset^® Podcast with Craig Domann, featuring Randy Lyman, author, speaker, and corporate leadership coach.

Most high performers believe the path to better results runs through better thinking and harder work. Think more clearly. Work more efficiently. Push harder. Build better systems. Optimize everything that can be optimized.

Randy Lyman spent decades believing the same thing. He built multiple companies, won national awards, achieved what most people would call significant success — all while keeping his emotions firmly locked away. Then, in 1999, three of his own management team walked into his office, closed the door, and told him the truth: the problems in his business were because of him.

It was the moment that cracked everything open. What Randy found underneath changed not just his leadership, but his entire understanding of why people succeed, why they fail, and why the mental game runs much deeper than most people ever dare to look.

He joined Pro Mindset^® Podcast host Craig Domann to break it all down — and the conversation was one of the most practically profound episodes the show has produced.

"Whatever we didn't feel completely when we had that original emotion — whether it's two weeks ago or twenty years ago — that energy is stored like gasoline in a metal can. It just waits to be experienced."— Randy Lyman

The Third Element Nobody Is Training

Randy's central framework — and the title of his book — is The Third Element.  Most people trying to improve their performance work on two variables: thoughts and actions. Think better, do better. That's the entire self-help industry in four words.

But there is a third element that determines whether the first two actually produce results – almost nobody trains it.

T

Thoughts

What most coaches, books, and programs focus on. Necessary but not sufficient.

A

Actions

The physical effort and execution. Hard work is real — but it runs on emotional fuel.

E

Emotions

The third element. The one that determines whether T + A actually produce results — or quietly collapses them.

Emotions, Randy explained, operate like energy under the first law of thermodynamics: they cannot be created nor destroyed. Whatever you feel in any given moment — joy, shame, fear, embarrassment — is part of your body's natural guidance system, generating physical hormones and reactions that either draw you toward something or push you away. But the moment you shut that process down — which most driven, high-achieving people learn to do early — that energy doesn't disappear. It gets stored. And it waits.

"I simply could not turn off my emotions," Randy said. "The emotions that I pushed down spilled into the rest of my life, clouded my judgment and kept me from working as hard as I could. It was the opposite of what I thought."

Why You Choke — It's Never What You Think

Craig asked Randy the question every coach, athlete, and competitor eventually confronts: why do capable people completely fall apart in the moments that matter most? The presentation is prepared. The play has been run a thousand times. The skill is there — yet something collapses.

Randy's answer was precise: it is almost never a capability issue. It is always an emotional one.

The culprit, he argued, is what he calls the inner child — the part of every person that carries the primal fear of failure, rejection, and being cast out from the tribe. Go back far enough in human history and that fear was literal: get expelled from the group and you die. The modern brain doesn't distinguish between getting cut from the team and getting exiled from the village. At the instinctual level, it registers the same.

The Inner Child Paradox: The inner child is also where creativity lives. Where joy lives. Where the drive to win, to connect, and to share something beautiful with other people comes from. You don't want to kill it — you just can't let it run the show. The goal is to honor it, work with it, and stop pretending it isn't there.

When stored emotional energy is triggered by a high-stakes moment, the child takes over — and the adult performer disappears. The solution isn't to think your way through it in real time. It's to do the emotional work off the field, before you need it. "I have to take the time outside of work, outside of the game," Randy said, "and invest the time in becoming aware of my emotions and finding a way to work through them."

"If I have an issue I can't solve quickly with my thoughts and my actions, then I have to say — what emotion do I need to feel? I do my breath work or journaling or whatever that is. That helps me find a solution in the physical world. It's like magic. But it's not." — Randy Lyman

The Seven Levels of Truth

One of the most powerful tools Randy shared was a drill-down exercise he calls the Seven Levels of Truth — a method for peeling back the surface reasons for fear and frustration until you reach the actual core belief driving the behavior.

He demonstrated it using his own real experience with incompetent employees at his company. The surface frustration was straightforward: people weren't doing their jobs well. But Randy kept asking — so what? What does that really mean? What's underneath that?

The Seven Levels of Truth — Randy's Real Example

1

My employees are incompetent and not doing their jobs well.

2

If they don't perform, we won't be profitable and customers won't trust us.

3

If customers don't trust us, they won't buy and we'll fail as a business.

4

If the business fails, I look like a failure.

5

If I look like a failure, my family will see me as incompetent.

6

If my family sees me as incompetent, they will reject me.

7

If I'm rejected by my tribe, I won't survive. — The primal fear underneath everything.

The insight that makes this exercise so valuable is that the surface problem almost never needs the surface solution. Randy wasn't struggling with incompetent employees — he was struggling with a twelve-year-old emotional wound around his own competence in his family's eyes. When he finally processed that emotion at a four-day business communications retreat — sobbing in front of fifteen people, releasing energy he had carried for over a decade — the employee problem at work resolved itself. Not because anyone changed their behavior, but because Randy changed.

What Burnout Is Really Telling You

Randy's explanation of burnout reframes the entire conversation around high-performance fatigue. The conventional model says burnout is the result of doing too much for too long — overwork, under-recovery, insufficient rest. Address those variables and you fix the problem.

Randy says the actual mechanism runs deeper. Every ambitious person starts their journey driven by emotional motivation: they want to feel successful, to provide for their family, to experience the joy of building something real – that drive is emotional at its core. But in order to execute — to show up and grind through difficulty — they suppress the emotions that make them feel vulnerable or distracted.

The Burnout Paradox: When you suppress the painful emotions to work harder, you also suppress the positive emotions that were fueling the work in the first place. The drive, the motivation, the sense of purpose — all of it runs on the same emotional current you just cut off. Eventually the tank runs dry. That's not overwork. That's self-disconnection.

The path back isn't a vacation. It's opening what Randy calls Pandora's box — allowing the full range of emotions, messy and uncomfortable and inconvenient, to move through you again. "When we work through the messy ones and we work through some of the pain," he said, "then we get in touch again with those goals we had of success, those goals of safety and sharing and taking care of our family."

"When we turn off our emotions to find success — eventually we lose the motivation. That's where burnout comes from." — Randy Lyman

What Men Suppress Most — And What It Costs Them

When Craig asked Randy to name the most common emotion men suppress and how it shows up later, the answer cut through everything: anger is the cover. It's the emotion most men are comfortable expressing because it feels powerful. Anger is almost always a distraction from what's underneath — loneliness, abandonment, and shame.

Shame was the last major emotional layer, Randy admitted, that he worked through — after 36 years of dedicated personal development work. He had shame about his shame, which was itself keeping him stuck. "As a very accomplished, capable, masculine man," he said, "I can tell you the most important part of what holds us back is the inner child that's afraid of failure and rejection."

Anger, at its root, often comes from a single place: unfairness. The rules we were taught don't match the rules that actually govern reality. Be a good boy. Show up. Do your homework. Get a good job. Those rules are not enough — and the gap between what we were promised and what we actually experience generates a rage that, without the right tools, never finds a productive release.

The Morning Goal Nobody Else Sets

Craig noted that in over 250 episodes of Pro Mindset Podcast, he had never heard a guest describe their morning routine the way Randy did. Most people set goals for output — calls to make, workouts to complete, tasks to check off. Randy sets a goal for an emotion.

Music First

Sets the emotional tone for the day and opens the door to deeper feeling before the work begins.

Goal: Feel Joy

A tear of gratitude — life is so beautiful that he's overwhelmed by it. This is a daily target, not an accident.

Goal: Release Old Pain

Intentionally surface and process a stored emotion. Not sobbing — just feeling at the deepest level available that day.

"I set one goal," Randy said. "I want to either cry a tear of joy because life is so freaking beautiful — or I want to get to a place where I heal some old emotion." The planning still happens. The goals still get written. But the emotional foundation gets laid first. When it does, everything built on top of it is sturdier.

"Everybody, including myself, is doing the best they can with what they know and where they are. They're not out to get me. They never were. I took it personal like they were." —Randy Lyman

The Bottom Line

Randy Lyman has spent 36 years doing the work most people spend their entire lives avoiding. Not because it's comfortable — it isn't. Not because it's quick — it isn't that either. But because every time he's gone to the deeper level, the problem at the surface has resolved. Every time he's processed what was stored, more capacity has opened up for what he was trying to build.

The third element isn't soft. It isn't optional. It isn't something you graduate from once you've read enough books or hit enough revenue milestones. It is the variable that determines whether everything else you're working on actually produces results — or quietly gets sabotaged by what you're carrying without knowing it.

Thoughts. Actions. Emotions. Train all three. The ones who do don't just perform better. They become someone different on the other side of the work.

Listen to the full conversation with Randy Lyman here or here. Connect with Craig for coaching opportunities on how to build your Pro Mindset^® Performance Bubble™ at Craig.ProMindset@gmail.com. Find Randy at https://randylyman.com/ and follow along for resources built for athletes, coaches, and the parents who support them.

Follow Us On:

Facebook: facebook.com/ProMindsetPod

Twitter: twitter.com/ProMindsetPod

Instagram: instagram.com/promindsetpodcast/

Linkedin: linkedin.com/company/pro-mindset

TikTok: tiktok.com/@pro.mindset.guy

YouTube: youtube.com/@promindsetpodcast

For more information about Craig and his keynote speaking, coaching, or NIL athlete representation, go to www.CraigDomann.com or contact him at Craig.ProMindset@gmail.com.